# Claude solves two open black hole physics problems — papers by Claude agents

> Claude agents finished a 2003 black hole calculation and found an exact bound physicists had only estimated.

- Org: Anthropic
- Date: 2026-11-17
- Category: showcase, paper
- Source: https://www.anthropic.com/research/claude-black-hole-physics
- Canonical page: https://ai-tldr.dev/releases/anthropic-claude-black-hole-physics/

## In short

Anthropic says Claude agents solved two open problems in black hole physics: the weak-coupling Hawking-Page transition and the exact modular bootstrap ceiling, about c/9.1266. Both papers were written by Claude and checked by a physicist.

## What it is

Anthropic's research post reports two results in theoretical physics produced by Claude. First, Claude completed a calculation set up in 2003 but never finished, showing that the Hawking-Page phase transition in N=4 super Yang-Mills stays abrupt (first order) at weak coupling. Second, it found the exact ceiling on the lightest black hole's mass in the spinless modular bootstrap, about c/9.1266, and proved it is optimal for that method.

## How it works

Researcher Hongbin Chen asked Claude to list open problems in black hole physics and the bootstrap method; it produced 22, and separate agents worked on them in the background for about six weeks. For the phase transition, a group of Claude copies did nearly every piece of the calculation twice, independently. For the bound, Claude spotted a pattern in numerical results and used a spectral curve from another area of mathematics to get the closed form, after 61 earlier parallel attempts had failed.

## Why it matters

Physicists had a proven bound of c/8.5 and numerical estimates near c/9.1; the new result pins the exact value. The papers name Anthropic as contributor and say Claude wrote them under light guidance, with a physicist checking the main results, so this is AI-led research rather than AI-assisted. The method still cannot reach c/12, where black holes first appear, so the bigger question stays open.

## Who it's for

physicists, mathematicians and people tracking AI for science

## Quick facts

- Project lead: Hongbin Chen, Anthropic
- Problem 1: Hawking-Page transition in N=4 super Yang-Mills at weak coupling
- Problem 2: Optimal modular bootstrap bound for 3D gravity
- Previous best bound: c / 8.5 proven; numerics near c / 9.1
- Run time: About six weeks of background agents on 22 candidate problems
- Checking: Physicist review; bootstrap result verified in Lean
- Papers: Hexagon 2611.00174 and 2611.00175, CC BY 4.0

## FAQ

### Which Claude model solved the black hole problems?

The modular bootstrap paper says an internal Claude research model first obtained the main result and that Claude Opus 5.5 later reproduced it. The Hawking-Page paper credits an internal Claude research model prompted by a physicist. Anthropic's post adds that a separate agent reached the same phase-transition answer before a physicist who was also using Claude.

### How were Claude's black hole physics results checked?

Anthropic says a physicist checked the main results. In the phase-transition work, independent Claude agents did nearly every piece of the calculation twice, and the paper reproduces known results such as the two-loop Hagedorn temperature. The bootstrap result was reached independently by two other agents and formally verified in Lean in September.

### Does Claude's modular bootstrap result prove pure 3D gravity exists?

No. Claude's exact ceiling of about c/9.1266 is the best this version of the modular bootstrap can do, and Anthropic says the method cannot reach c/12, where black holes first appear. Settling that question needs other ingredients. The result does replace the earlier proven bound of c/8.5 by Hartman, Mazáč and Rastelli.

### Where can I read Claude's black hole physics papers?

Both papers are posted on Hexagon under a CC BY 4.0 license: 'The spinless modular bootstrap at large central charge' (2611.00174) and 'The Hawking-Page transition at weak coupling' (2611.00175). Version 1 of each was posted on November 7, 2026, ten days before Anthropic's announcement, and the phase-transition paper is labeled as primarily AI-generated text.

## Links

- [Announcement](https://www.anthropic.com/research/claude-black-hole-physics)
- [Bootstrap Paper](https://hexagonmath.org/2611.00174v1)
- [Hawking-Page Paper](https://hexagonmath.org/2611.00175v1)
