█

AI/TLDR

Mani Doraisamy · 2026-11-20 · notable

Mani Doraisamy — AI coding quietly promoted developers into architects

In short

Mani Doraisamy argues AI coding tools turn developers into architects: AI builds what the requirements say but never pushes back. In his example, vibe-coded install logging made an add-on's welcome screen take about 15 seconds.

Mani Doraisamy · 2026-11-20 · 2 sources checked

Thumbnail for Mani Doraisamy's essay on developers becoming architects

When AI writes the code, the developer's real job becomes the design decisions AI will not question.

What is it?

"We promoted developers into architects without informing them" is an essay by Mani Doraisamy that reached 462 points on Hacker News. Doraisamy argues that AI coding tools have moved developers from writing code to making architecture decisions, and that most were never told.

How does it work?

His example is a Google Forms add-on. A colleague vibe-coded logging for new installs, and because Google restricts user data, the AI wrote a chain of try/catch blocks: try the email, then the user ID, then log a bare install. Each line made several Google API calls before the welcome screen, so it took about 15 seconds to load. His fixes are to log only a timestamp, or to show the screen first and log in the background.

Why does it matter?

Doraisamy says AI follows functional, security and compatibility requirements but does not know an app's scale or stage, so it cannot make trade-offs like timestamp versus email. His advice: push back on requirements, design the data model first, keep the AI inside that design and review its output as an architect would.

Who is it for?

developers and team leads using AI coding tools

Sources · 2 outlets

Tags

  • vibe-coding
  • ai-coding
  • software-architecture
  • coding-agents
  • code-review
  • essay
  • hacker-news

← All releases · Learn AI